All field notes

Build a useful client community before it has members

A client community should make a recurring customer problem easier to solve. Opening an empty discussion board and sending invitations leaves that job to the first visitors. Before recruiting, design a useful first visit and a reason to return that fits your service and your capacity to facilitate it.

Start with a member promise

Define who belongs and what they can accomplish together. “Operations leads comparing practical proposal workflows” gives you a sharper starting point than “a community for business growth.” Explain membership terms, expected conduct, commercial relationships, privacy boundaries and the role of your team. A member should know whether this is peer support, paid education or a sales-supported group.

Choose a simple platform based on how the intended members already work. A small scheduled discussion with a shared resource index may be sufficient. Additional channels create empty rooms and extra moderation obligations. Build complexity only after repeated use makes a specific need clear.

Seed useful material without pretending there are members

Publish a welcome note, a starting checklist, an original worked example, a short resource index and a few carefully framed discussion prompts. Label staff-authored answers as staff contributions. Label sample records as demonstrations. Obtain permission for case studies and use licensed material. Never create fake member identities, invented endorsements or misleading activity counts.

Make the first task concrete: “Share the one approval step that repeatedly delays a proposal, without naming clients or exposing confidential information.” Provide a template and your own clearly identified example. The person who joins first can then understand the expected depth and privacy standard.

Recruit founding participants through a real relationship

Invite a handful of suitable clients, former clients or willing professional contacts individually. Explain the early stage and the commitment: for example, one facilitated discussion and an optional follow-up. An invitation should offer a useful activity, not ask people to rescue an empty platform. Do not add anyone to a mailing list or group without permission.

Run the first session yourself. Introduce people with consent, connect similar problems and summarize usable lessons. Answer unanswered questions within a boundary you can sustain. If members need specialist advice outside the group's scope, say so. A supportive community is not a substitute for every professional service.

Measure whether participation helps

Count meaningful first actions, questions receiving a useful response, time to that response and voluntary return participation. Define “useful response” explicitly, such as an answer the asker confirms helped them progress. Track unresolved threads and the staff hours required. Raw member count can rise while the actual experience deteriorates.

In a fictional first session, eight invitees produce four attendees and two follow-up contributions. Those observations suggest a starting conversation, not product-market fit. Ask attendees what they used afterward and ask willing nonattendees whether timing, relevance or the invitation caused the mismatch. Do not treat all absence as disinterest.

Expand only when the first experience works

Create a recurring rhythm around a problem members already revisit: a monthly workflow clinic, for example. Give new arrivals an obvious orientation and preserve useful answers in a searchable index. Ask before republishing member contributions outside the group. When members begin helping each other without constant prompting, invite another suitable cohort and check whether response quality holds. Community growth is a service-delivery responsibility as well as a marketing channel.

Keep learning

Browse all articles

Want this applied to your business? The Growth Fix is one fixed-price session to find where your customers drop off and fix the part that matters most.

Ashley Kays

Ashley Kays

Founder

Founder of Waymaker. BigCo veteran (NCR, Walt Disney World, Wyndham Worldwide) turned solo operator. Building the operating layer above AI building tools.

More field notes